Dark Pools Explained

What are Dark Pools?

A dark pool is a private exchange or forum for trading securities away from public exchanges. Their key characteristic is that dark pools do not display order books like traditional public exchanges, keeping trading interest and liquidity hidden until after a trade is executed.

How Dark Pools Work

Dark pools operate by allowing participants to enter anonymous orders, which are then crossed or matched based on predetermined rules and order types. Orders are not displayed publicly, and matched counterparties are kept confidential. The mechanics involve complex algorithms and matching engines to facilitate off-exchange trading in this opaque manner.

Benefits of Dark Pool Trading

A key advantage of dark pools is reducing the risk of information leakage and market impact costs when executing large orders. By concealing trading interest, institutions can make large block trades with counterparties while minimizing price movements that pre-trade transparency could trigger. Dark pools also offer lower trading fees compared to public exchanges.

Dark Pool Strategies and Participants

Major users are institutional investors like mutual funds looking to trade large volumes with reduced market impact. Common dark pool strategies involve using algorithms to slice and dice large orders across multiple venues and timeframes. Leading operators include banks and brokers like Goldman Sachs and UBS.

Controversies Around Dark Pools

While beneficial for large trades, dark pools have faced criticism over a lack of pre-trade transparency, potential conflicts of interest when run by brokers, and concerns over fair access. Critics argue that such markets increase the risks of abuse and front-running by some participants. High frequency traders may be able to detect and exploit dark pool activity.

Dark Pool Regulation and Oversight

To address these issues, regulators have focused on increasing oversight and reporting of off-exchange trading activity. In the U.S., the SEC requires dark pool operators to register as ATSs and follow the rules around fair access, fee disclosure, interaction with public quotations, and transparency. Similar regulatory frameworks exist in other major markets.

Dark Pool Statistics and Data

While opaque by nature, some high-level data exists on dark pool volumes and trade sizes. Dark pools are part of the 59 execution venues in the United States, including 12 exchanges, various broker-dealer operated venues, and also dark pools.

Darkpool handle over 10% of consolidated equity volume for larger trades, and monitoring dark pool metrics provides insight into their overall activity levels.

Dark Pool Indicators and Technology

To help detect potential dark pool activity, analytics providers have developed various algorithms and strategies focused on identifying dark pool footprints. Some tools analyze order book data and trade patterns to estimate the presence and involvement of dark liquidity. Technology plays a key role in navigating these non-displayed liquidity pools.

Alexander Voigt, CEO
Article by
Alexander Voigt is the founder of DayTradingZ, was a regular contributor to Benzinga and has been featured and quoted on leading financial websites such as Investors.com, Capital.com, Business Insider and Forbes.